Summery Herbed Tomato Pie

I want to share this recipe for Summery Herbed Tomato Pie with you. It is that good. It sounded pretty nasty to me at first but now I love it!

For real, this is good stuff.

I originally found this recipe in a Gooseberry Patch recipe book, promptly said "ewww" and moved on. For some strange reason I actually decided to try it one day. Probably because I had 5 tomatoes very close to going bad on my counter. And a pie crust.

And it was so good. Hubby was just as surprised as I was and now it's one of his favorite meals. I don't make it regularly, partly because we PIG OUT on it!

Summery Herbed Tomato Pie {adapted from Gooseberry Patch Best Ever Casseroles}

Serves 8-10                              Cook Time: 35 minutes


9-in pie crust {I use Pillsbury ready made refrigerated pie crust}
3-4 tomatoes, sliced
1/4-1/2 cup fresh chives, chopped {the original recipe calls for 1/2 cup but it always looks like too much when I put it in so I usually do a bit less. Also, I have used freeze-dried chopped chives for this and it still turns out well}
2T fresh basil, chopped
2 cups shredded or grated mozzarella cheese
1/2 cup mayonnaise
Salt and pepper to taste

Press pie crust into a 9" pie plate. Bake at 425 degrees for 5 minutes. Reduce oven to 400 degrees. Arrange tomato slices in crust; sprinkle with chives, basil, salt, and pepper. Combine cheese and mayonnaise; spread over tomatoes. Bake at 400 degrees for 35 minutes.

I promise this is delicious! And super easy to put together quickly! It goes great with a side salad. And I'm not sure who came up with the 8-10 servings because we can almost polish it off in one sitting, gluttons that we are. I can't wait until I can make it with tomatoes from our own little garden, which I haven't killed yet, in case you were wondering.

I hope you enjoy it as much as we do!

Dear Creatives

Link Parties:
House of Hepworths~Hookin' Up with House of Hepworths
Liz Marie Blog~Inspire Me
Suburbs Mama
VMG206~DIY Showcase
My Snippets of Inspiration
Rain On A Tin Roof~Give Me The Goods Monday
Happy Wifey~Happy Monday Show and Share
Love Grows Wild~Time To Sparkle
Hickory Trail~Efforts and Assets
Bebetsy and VMG206~Brag About It
Smart School House~Whimsy Wednesday
I Gotta Create!~Wildly Original
Blissful and Domestic~Feature Friday


  1. This sounds amazing! Just wish my Mr. ate tomatoes! :( Ps. I have tried to kill my tomato plants 3x now, and they are still kicking! They got blight in Early May, (ps, if you're get blight, let me know, I have a non chemical solution for you!!!) then we moved and tried to move my containers on the back of a trailer, and they got wind burnt, then they got bugs so someone told me to spray diluted dawn detergent on them to kill the bugs and stay organic, bad idea, don't do it! They've seen better days, but they are still kicking!!!!

    1. Haha mine doesn't care for tomatoes either, but he LOVES this. You should make it anyway, even if it's just for you! It's so good!

      Too funny about the tomatoes! I was under the impression that they were quite the delicate plant. Glad you still have them!

  2. Holy moley does that look delicious! I just bought tomatoes because I'm in the mood but had no idea what I was going to do with them. It's like an encrusted, cheese filled ratatouille!

  3. Oh my word. I may have died and gone to heaven. This sounds amazing! Pinning and making when my tomatoes come in! Jenna @ Rain on a Tin Roof

  4. This looks delicious! My herb garden is taking over and the tomatoes are about to do the same, so this will be a perfect recipe to use up some of our overabundance! :)

  5. Mmmmm, I love tomato pie! I usually use cheddar, so I'll have to try this with mozzarella. I'm visiting from Rain on a Tin Roof link party.

    Christy @ Creating a Beautiful Life

    1. I might have to try cheddar now. Sounds good! Thanks for visiting!

  6. WOW, this looks delish! Thank you for linking with HickoryTrail

  7. Wow! looks delicious and cheesy. We love tomatoes and I am always looking for yummy recipes - this one is perfect! (Sharon)

    So glad you linked up with us at the BeBetsy BRAG ABOUT IT Link and Hop.

    We'd love it if you would link back to BeBetsy.

    Have a great week~xo
    Sharon and Denise!

    1. Thanks for the link up reminder! I did it last time and forgot this time. Thanks for the party!

  8. Oh man, I can't wait until my tomatoes start coming in in my garden now! This looks AMAZING. I wonder if you could substitute greek yogurt for the mayo to make it a little lighter?
    Heidi @

    1. Hi Heidi! I usually use light mayo to lighten it up but greek yogurt might work well too. You could try it and see and let me know how it goes!

  9. This is the perfect recipe for tomato season! Thanks for visiting & sharing at the party Theresa @ Hope to see you again soon.

  10. Forgot to tell you I am featuring you this Friday! Be sure to drop by & grab your featured button!

  11. WOW! Cheesy goodness! Thank you so much for linking up! Hope to see more from you.

  12. Thanks so much for sharing this at my Happy Monday Show & Share @! I featured this because it looks GREAT!


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...